How the rate is made
keepvote asks readers a single question and counts the answers by fixed, public rules. This page explains how votes become a rate, a verdict and a seal – and what the number does not mean.
One question
Anyone who bought a product answers one question: kept or sent back? Anyone who did not buy it skips the question and only sees the result. There are no stars and no free-text reviews.
Purchases are not verified
We see no receipts and link no accounts. Every vote is a statement by a reader. That is why the rate is labelled “reader vote” – and why we protect the vote carefully.
The keep rate
The rate is the share of “kept” among all “kept” and “returned” votes. It appears from the first vote – as a snapshot: next to every rate we show how many votes it is based on. With few votes it can still change a lot; every further vote makes it more accurate. Below 5 votes we show it in a muted grey, from 5 votes in colour. Without votes there is no number.
The verdict
A verdict (“Most people keep it” or “Often sent back – read up first”) and a place in the top lists require at least 50 votes, cast on at least 7 different days from at least 10 different networks. This way no single day and no single group can make a verdict.
Time frame
Rate and verdict count all votes since the start. The top lists also exist for the last week and the last month. The seal is stricter: it looks at a rolling window of the last 90 days.
The keepvote seal
A product earns the seal through votes alone. These criteria apply:
- Keep rate of at least 80 %, rolling over the last 90 days.
- At least 100 votes on at least 30 different days.
- Votes from at least 10 different networks.
- Votes under review and votes from data centres do not count.
What never counts
- Robots and automated tools.
- Traffic from data centres.
- Devices and networks of the operator – including our own tests.
- Networks in quarantine after an attempt at manipulation.
- Votes that are still under review.
One vote per device and product
Each device has one vote per product. If you change your mind, you change your vote – it then counts anew, not twice. For this, your device creates a random identifier only when you vote; all that reaches us is a value that cannot be reversed.
How we protect the vote
Every vote passes several checks before it counts: origin, behaviour, a small computing task in the browser and limits per device and network. Anything unusual goes to review and does not count until then. We do not publish details that would help attackers.
What the rate is not
- Not representative: the voters are readers who find keepvote – not a random sample.
- Not a return rate: retailers count returns differently; our number rests only on what readers tell us.
- Not a test and no statement about quality, safety or the environment.
- A snapshot: every new vote can change the rate.
Independent
keepvote sells no products. Partnerships with retailers, commissions and seal licences never influence votes, rate, verdict or ranking. Votes cannot be bought.
How to cite
Please cite as: “keepvote.com, reader vote, as of [date]” – with the link to the page you used. The rate means: “X % of voting keepvote readers say: kept” – not a test result.
Rules valid since: